Ever notice how the people who constantly complain
that “we can’t say what we really think anymore because everyone is so
politically correct nowadays” actually have no problem saying whatever they
want, at any volume they want, and often seem to encounter a huge crowd of
like-minded peers?
The complaint that “everyone believes X” is one of those opinions that actually becomes less true depending
on how many people believe it. Because if the majority is complaining about a
supposedly omnipresent belief, then that belief cannot be as pervasive as they
say.
This is why I can’t buy the whole “Oh no, the whole
world is turning into Tumblr!” claim. Yes, there are communities on Tumblr that
use social justice as a cover to bully people, or who misuse SJ theory for
personal gain within their groups of friends, or who get angry at others for
being genuinely uninformed. There are also those who expect a person to change
their entire worldview within the course of a single conversation and then get
upset when they don’t. Because I care about social justice, I think it’s
important to acknowledge these problems that exist within some Tumblr
communities. But the world is not Tumblr. Even the most seemingly polarizing SJ
groups are a backlash against an opposing status quo. And yes, there are people
who want to make the rest of the world like those aforementioned groups, but
they generally don’t have influence beyond their specific social crowd. These
are not the people who are running the world.
College campuses are used as examples of ways in
which some negative approaches to social justice are gaining traction. While
there are campuses in which students have done certain things I disagree with,
a college campus is also not a microcosm of the larger world. It’s a
sub-community, and a very small one at that. Also, we forget that college
undergrads are usually young. They could likely change the way they are
expressing themselves as time goes on, and adopt a more productive approach to
social justice.
So yes, there are factions of the social justice
sphere which are imperfect, and that needs to be recognized. But those factions
are not even the entire social justice world, let alone the larger world in
itself.